Who Will Take the Reigns? Death in Paradise Fans Debate the Next Lead Detective

The sunny shores of Saint Marie are a mainstay for fans of the light-hearted detective drama Death in Paradise. But with the departure of DI Neville Parker (played by Ralf Little), a storm is brewing amongst viewers. Who will be the next detective to solve Saint Marie's perplexing murders?

Fan Casting Throws Shade on Hollywood Takeover

Ever since news broke of Little's exit, speculation has been rampant about his replacement. Bookies currently favor Harry Potter alum Rupert Grint, but a social media post by show writer James Hall hinting at an American actor has some fans crying foul.

Many viewers expressed their disapproval on the show's Facebook page, arguing that a British actor would be a more fitting choice.  One fan commented, "Why on earth would an American actor pretend to be British? There are plenty of British actors about."  Another echoed the sentiment, stating, "Please, he's a good actor but not right for DIP [Death in Paradise]."

Kelby for Saint Marie? Fan Favorite Emerges from Spin-Off

While some fans resist the idea of a Hollywood import, others are championing a character from the Death in Paradise spin-off series, Beyond Paradise.  Officer Kelby Hartford (played by Dylan Llewellyn) has emerged as a popular contender.  His bumbling charm seems to resonate with viewers, with one fan enthusiastically declaring, "Kelby is the best character in the Death in Paradise universe #beyondparadise!"  Another playfully envisioned his future, "Kelby is so me... bet he solves the case...promotion to St Marie #beyondparadise."

Former Stars Offer Casting Choices

Adding fuel to the fire, former Death in Paradise leads have weighed in with their picks.  Ben Miller, who played the show's inaugural detective,  advocated for Toby Jones, while also expressing his desire for a female lead. "There are so many people who'd be brilliant," Miller mused, before adding, "Toby Jones, that's who I'd like to see."  He further championed the idea of a woman detective, suggesting actresses like Miranda Hart, stating, "I could see that, 100 percent. I think that'd be good too."

The Verdict: A Casting Mystery Still Unfolds

With filming for the new season yet to begin, the identity of the next lead detective remains a mystery.  Whether producers will appease fans' desires for a British actor or a familiar face from the Death in Paradise universe is anyone's guess.  One thing is certain: the wait for the next chapter in Saint Marie's captivating story is sure to keep fans buzzing.

What do you think? Who would be your ideal replacement for DI Neville Parker? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

FAQs

1. Why is there so much speculation about the next lead detective?

Death in Paradise has a history of lead detective departures, making casting announcements a highly anticipated event for fans.

2. Who are the frontrunners to replace Ralf Little?

Bookmakers currently favor Rupert Grint, but fan campaigns for Kelby Hartford and a yet-to-be-announced British actor are gaining traction.

3.  Have former cast members weighed in on the casting?

Yes. Ben Miller, who played the show's first detective,  advocated for Toby Jones and expressed his desire for a female lead.

4. When will we know who the next detective is?

With filming yet to begin, an official announcement is likely forthcoming, though a specific date hasn't been revealed.

5. How can I stay updated on Death in Paradise casting news?

Following the show's social media pages and entertainment news websites are your best bets for staying current on casting announcements.